Wednesday, November 27, 2013

Hardly Ever an Unkind Word

At the time I didn't know who she was - an old woman bundled up in a heavy coat, sitting on a blanket in a neighborhood park on a cold mid-November day, listening to music.  I was up and moving partly to capture the faces in the crowd, partly to keep warm and it was her face that drew me - her life was written on it and she'd clearly done some hard traveling - the deeply etched lines and wrinkles and the small signs of skin cancer gave it away.  When I pointed my camera at her, she instinctively tilted her head and gave me a hint of a smile, but her eyes flashed as if they were dancing.  I snapped the shutter, having no idea how important this single photo would be be one day, until yesterday when I saw that she'd died.  At 76, she'd earned her rest.

She'd also earned her way.  She'd raised one son and then two grandchildren, all musicians, on something like $800 a month for years, no small thing.  She'd seen her family through all the hard times and heartache, often their only means of transportation to and from various venues.  She'd worked the door, helped carry gear, saw them safely home.  And nobody could've been more encouraging or supportive of their music, even when the music itself strayed outside the lines.  She'd fed and sheltered them through it all with very little thought of herself and hardly ever an unkind word.  She was very good at putting herself in the shoes of another, thought it was important not to judge or criticize, especially if about someone else's dreams.  Death has a way of making us look back, often adding a soft focus to what we see and remember, a small and forgivable bit of editing in most cases but sometimes it isn't necessary - sometimes the memories are all too adequate and need no adornments, no extra kindness.

I can't credit the following quote but I doubt I've ever read truer words.

Grief never ends.
But it changes.
It's a passage, not a place to stay.
Grief is not a sign of weakness nor a lack of faith.
It's the price of love.


Tuesday, November 26, 2013

And That's What It's All About

It was midway through a Monday morning from hell when the credit card machine decided to dig in its heels and fail halfway through a transaction.  The display abruptly went wild for a few seconds, lights flashed and warning tones chirped, then it went dark.  Three 'phone lines were simultaneously ringing, the doctor was hovering over my shoulder demanding to know if the printer repairman had called, there was a line at the glass window and another at the check out counter and not a nurse in sight.  I felt like a firework in mid explosion.

A young-ish sounding and calm-voiced tech support guy named John took my call, first inquiring after my health - I was in no mood to chit chat and made that clear - he immediately apologized, asked a few routine questions and then put me on hold.  When he came back, he warned me that it was a complicated fix but that he'd walk me through it.  I growled.

Are you ready? he asked, There's a lot of steps so be sure you have room.

Yes! I snapped, too angry and impatient to wonder what the hell room had to do with it.

Ok, he said with that irritating level-headedness, Put your left foot in.

My hand froze above the screen.  

What??  I demanded incredulously.

Put your left foot in, he repeated serenely, Then put your left foot out.

Certain I'd crossed into The Twilight Zone, I stood there with my hand poised over the LED and tried to make sense of what I was hearing.

Now, he continued placidly, Hit enter and then punch 9.

Instantly the screen lit up correctly.  


That's it???  I couldn't believe it.

That's it, he assured me and I could've sworn he laughed, But I thought you needed to smile.

John....I kept my tone even, couldn't have been able to stay mad if I'd tried,  You know, nobody likes a wise ass merchant services guy.

Then he did laugh and so did I.  Because sometimes the Hokey Pokey really is what it's all about.

And that's a true story.




Sunday, November 24, 2013

Separate Ways

The signs are unmistakable. 

It's a muggy November day, a Sunday, and rather than blowing leaves or hanging security lights or smoking meat in the backyard, my neighbor Kevin is loading a pickup truck.  His face is grim and tight and he strides back and forth with armful after armful of possessions, haphazardly tossing them into the truck bed with angry, disjointed motions.  There's no sign of Sharon, his wife, and no yapping little Maltese at his heels. This, I realize, is a husband on his way out.

You work too hard, Kevin, I call to him as I unload groceries.

Seems so, he tells me, That's why I'm getting a divorce.

And even though I instinctively knew it, to have it put out there, hanging in the humid air, stops me in my tracks.  I tell him I'm sorry to hear it but he just shrugs.

They've lived next door for the last five or so years and while I don't know them well, I have gotten used to them being there.  He's a worker bee - spending every free evening and weekend hour building or puttering with home improvement projects.  Landscaping and a fire pit for the back yard, repairs to the fence, cutting and stacking wood for the fireplace, planting roses and trimming trees, installing an awning over the patio. I find myself remembering how my second husband always managed to have a half dozen projects in the works - anything to put some distance between us and drink unobserved - and begin to wonder if what I've been assuming was industry might've been avoidance.  A house, two cars in the driveway and a little dog don't make a home and all too often love is fleeting if not pitifully inadequate against the inevitable storms.  You can love unreservedly - often without even working very hard at it - but it takes real effort to live with someone, to adapt and compromise and sacrifice and bend.  I've learned that not all of us are cut out for a lifetime of togetherness and harder still, not all of us should try.

When divorce was a scandal, couples stayed together whether they should've or not.  No surrender.

Now that it's common as dirt, people give up without a second thought.  No resistance.

I'm glad that we're past the illusions but sometimes I wonder if the whole concept isn't obsolete.

His belongings neatly and securely lashed in the cargo bed, Kevin's shiny and well cared for pickup truck eases out of the driveway and down the street.   In the front window of the house he leaves behind, a curtain stirs and then is still. 











Friday, November 22, 2013

Winter Roses

Despite the change of season, the roses are thriving.  They seem to go from tightly closed buds to full petals almost overnight, undeterred by the cold or the wind or the rain, reaching for the sunlight with all their energy and optimism.  They have hope and potential and a vision for the future and passing by them each morning brightens my day just a little.  It's little enough comfort in a world gone dizzyingly mad, a reminder that we are all struggling to get through the day and fighting private battles.

More often than not, my battles are with myself, with the person I want to be and the one I am.  I've lived too long to tolerate the overwhelming stupidity and rudeness of the general public, worked too hard to be bullied no matter how reasonable and soft the voice may be, and spent too much time and effort trying to quietly fade into the background.  The old woman who wears purple no longer peers out from behind her garden gate - more and more often she swings it wide open and invites you in for a cup of arsenic-laced tea.  Would that I had the will to be more like the roses, swaying gently in the chilly November wind and lifting their velvety petaled faces upward.  I would hide my thorns but keep them sharpened - for self defense only in the event someone tried to pick me.

The old woman who wears purple, however, is more weed-like.  She's a little faded, her roots go a little deeper, she has a long memory and a short temper.  Her thorns are stubbornness and impatience and an overall world weariness.  Somewhere along the way, she's lost her faith and replaced it with cynicism and doubt.  She's on the road to isolationism, with any luck, to a small house with locked doors overlooking an ocean in a country she's always wished she'd been born to. 

Friends will be welcome - provided they bring American cigarettes, eat sparingly and don't stay overlong - but mostly I imagine retirement as another word for retreat, a time to sort myself out and revel in the remaining years.  I'd like to think that the anger that has sustained me all my life will drift out to sea and harmlessly dissipate.  I'd like to think that I can do without it and live quietly with my animals, my camera, my books.

Maybe I'll even plant roses.  

Although I'm leaning toward poison ivy.












Sunday, November 17, 2013

A Side of Frozen Shoulder, Please

On the blessedly rare morning when I find myself feeling creaky and old, I usually try to remind myself of how fortunate I really am - compared to most of my friends, I'm in remarkable shape.  I still have most if not all of my original parts, have no persistent or even mildly annoying aches or pains as might be expected, no chronic conditions except a little routine bronchitis and until recently wasn't taking so much as a single medication. To be sure, it's not as easy as it used to be to untangle myself from sitting Indian style (but I can still do it) and sometimes I need a hand to help me up if I'm been kneeling to take a picture, but on the whole, I rarely feel my age although I suspect I look every year of it.  So when my right shoulder and arm began acting up this past summer, I ignored it - I believe in always trying denial first - and as it worsened, I learned to compensate.  I paid attention to which movements hurt and which didn't and practiced being careful, favoring my right side when necessary, mostly learning to adapt and telling myself it wasn't so bad.  And then one morning I reached behind my back to fasten the clasp on my bra and my arm and shoulder imploded with a fierce burning pain that lasted long after I let go.  Not long after that, putting on and taking off my scrub top began to make my shoulder twinge, one careless reach sideways would bring on a disabling spasm, one stretch of my right arm toward anything meant a bright burning sensation that took its sweet time fading away and it became more and more difficult to find a sleep position that didn't ache.  Finally convinced it was likely a rotater cuff injury and would have to be looked at, I reluctantly made an appointment with the orthopaedist, and spent one entire miserable week fretting about worst case scenarios involving casts, disability paperwork, loss of income, a bill I wouldn't live long enough to pay and pain.  Lots of pain.  By the day of the appointment, I was perilously close to changing my mind, then as I stepped into my bra and pulled it over my ankles, my knees, and my hips until I got to my shoulders, I caught a glimpse of myself in the full length mirror.

Jesus wept, I told the mirror image, You're too damn old to be playing at acrobatics.  Go get this done.

The doctor - khakis and a button down shirt, gold rimmed glasses, fluffy silver hair and kind eyes - was immediately reassuring.  He peered at xrays and then manipulated my arm into a variety of positions, tested for weakness and strength, noted each wince, and then pronounced it to be "frozen shoulder" - nowheres near as dramatic as a torn rotater cuff - but far less serious, easily treatable with stretching exercises, and transitory.  The technical name for it was "adhesive capsulitis", common in folks between 40 and 60.

You're outside the range, he admitted with a quick glance at the chart, but not by much, and gave me a smile to take the sting out of this remark.

I smiled back, foolishly grateful and a tad indignant at the same time.  

Between a bout of tennis elbow (I could lift 50 pounds without half trying but couldn't staple two pieces of paper together) and a case of trigger thumb ( almost hated to have that fixed, I got a little transfixed by the clicking noise it made when it released) and now frozen shoulder, I'm beginning to feel a little like a side of beef.

So I think I'll tell people I've had adhesive capsulitis, lateral epicondylitis, and digial tenovaginitis stenosans.
It sounds so much more sophisticated and just a tiny bit romantic.






Thursday, November 14, 2013

Tick Tock Habits

Having never given a stray thought to retirement until recently, I now find it much on my mind, especially after a night of sleeping in fits and starts - an hour here, an hour there - until the little alarm clock trills (well, actually it shatters the morning stillness like a fire siren) and all the animals seems to rise and shine as one. Of course they've been on and off awake since about three, accommodating each of my tosses and turns with a stubborn push back and now they're hungry and impatient for food and attention.  If there's one thing they all universally understand, it's that damn alarm clock.  Five in the morning and it's a free-for-all.

Except for a random year here and there, I've worked all my life and have never been able to imagine not doing so.  I like routine and stability and being counted upon, having a place to go where I'm needed and a desk of my own, the security of a paycheck.  Being useful and having a clear role to play is comforting and familiar.  Until recently, I'd never thought about not working just as I'd never thought about dying but now in the quiet of the night when I can't sleep and all I hear is the tick tock of the little clock above my head and the animals' slow, steady breathing, new and radical thoughts drift through my mind.  Sleeping 'til seven or even eight.  Actually taking a vacation.  Not having to be anywhere at a specified time.  Grocery shopping during the week.  Freedom vs idleness.  Time on my hands and no demands save what I impose on myself.  Work is a habit, a necessary evil if you haven't the foresight to come from or marry money and I'm beginning to wonder if it might not be time for a change.  My five year plan is starting to look too long.  With a part time job, I think idly, could I do it in three?  Could I do it in less?

The entire idea is so foreign that it almost doesn't compute but I'm slowly and tentatively learning to like it.

Meanwhile, I try to be like Charlie Brown and "dread one day at a time".














 

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

Three Pounds of Persistence

Never underestimate the power of a cat-can-do attitude.

In the two maybe three seconds it took for me to turn my back to reach for the mustard, the new kitten had sunk her tiny teeth into the unfinished salami sandwich and was in travelin' mode, dragging it backwards across the counter despite its weight and the fact that it was nearly half her size. 

Disengage! I cried in alarm and she glared at me - very kittenesque - and when I reached for it, she gave a small, plaintive meow and actually hung on.  I couldn't help but laugh at this one-sided contest and when the sandwich was finally free, I relented at her disappointed (and mad) little face and gave her a kitten-sized bite.
She trotted off so proudly I wasn't sure who had actually won.  I poured a glass of milk and turned with it and sandwich in hand only to stumble over the three dogs/witnesses.  I managed to save the milk but the poor salami never had a chance.

Dear Lord, I often think, give me patience.

I suppose the real trick is not to pray for a better life but rather the strength to endure and appreciate the one you have.  

                                  ----------------------------------------------------------------------

As if she were leading a cavalry charge, the kitten comes from nowhere, racing at full speed across the kitchen floor.  She clears one sleeping cat without breaking a sweat, side swipes a second which causes a brief flare up
and a nasty word or two, gains the coffee table easily and then with a determined kitten war whoop, flings her little self on top of the sleeping and unsuspecting small brown dog.  The dog yelps - unhurt but scared half to death - and immediately burrows into my side for protection, trembling and whimpering.  While I reassure her, the kitten moves on to the little dachshund - she pounces ferociously on his feathery tail and he whips around, pinning her down with one shaggy paw - she gives an indignant squeak of protest but she's nailed and she knows it.

What goes around, comes around, I tell her without much sympathy, Grin and bear it.

                                     -------------------------------------------------------------------------

You'd think after living with cats all these years, I'd have learned to recognize a set up.

Reaching down to retrieve a stray sock from the floor, I'm completely unprepared for the new kitten to erupt from under the bed and with a pigeon-like attack trill, leap and fasten herself around my wrist.  Caught entirely off guard, I jump in surprise and mutter a mild curse - it takes several seconds to peel her off - and I let her think it's her idea when she finally lets go and darts back under the bed, readying herself, I suspect, for the next passerby.  From where she's lying in the doorway, the black dog watches this intently and after a moment or two, she crawls in the direction of the bed and cautiously pokes her nose under the bedspread.  An instant later, a tiny gray paw appears and gives her a smart smack on the nose - she yelps, then growls, then tries her best to force her way under the bed, receiving a second swat for her trouble.  The kitten takes full advantage of her confusion and scrambles out the other side before she can free herself.

I'm still searching for the other sock.

                                    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

On a damp and chilly November morning, the kitten navigates like Magellan - from the floor to the bed in back of me, then a confident jump to my left shoulder, and finally into my lap - where she settles contentedly and begins to purr.  Rather than stay settled however, she is soon randomly reaching one small paw toward the keyboard and snagging my sleeve with her nails in an effort to distract me.  A kitten in search of attention is impossible to ignore - she's three pounds of persistence - and besides being bold as brass and fearless, this little one has a streak of mule in her.

Her other side, though, is sweetness and light.  She will just as easily curl up in the curve of the little dachshund's belly and fall fast asleep as charge him like some runaway whirling dervish.  And there's barely a whisper of protest when all three dogs fall onto her and play tug of war with her tail and ears as if she's just the best pull toy they've ever had.  She can rough and tumble with the best of them and then this afternoon, at her second vet visit - despite the unfamiliar environment, the noise, the smells - she was so relaxed she fell asleep while we were waiting.

At the foot of the couch, the kitten nestles in her new blanket and sleeps peacefully in the afternoon sunlight.
When the little dachshund jumps up to join her, she barely stirs - even when he sighs and lays his head across her small body, all she can manage is a sleepy look - and in just a few seconds, both are asleep.  By bedtime, he will be his usual calm, sweet self but she will be well rested and ready to take on the world.  

To me, nothing says home like a slightly schizophrenic kitten.









Sunday, November 10, 2013

The In-Between Times

It's the in-between times that get you, those brief and shining moments when you allow yourself the delusion that things will get better, will change, will pass.

My friend, Joann, struggling with the responsibility of a father lost to Alzheimer's and a helpless, victimized mother, is learning just how strong she is.  The emotional toll is enormous, the physical demands intolerable.
One moment he's there - knows who she is and is rational and calm - then he's gone and in his place there's an abusive, physically violent stranger, a monster who presents a real danger to himself and his family.  None of the medications are helping - some even appear to make it worse - and it's about to get worse as he faces discharge from the hospital and being sent home to recover from a broken hip.  The idea of a nursing home is brought up and quickly dismissed, no one is quite willing to consign him to that particular brand of hell, not yet anyway and besides it would break them financially.  A professional nurse/caregiver is suggested but the patient is unmanageable and would be a threat to their safety, finding the right one has so far proved impossible.  Visions of her daddy in restraints and medicated to this side of a coma are too grim to even consider, yet where else is there to turn.  How long is long enough for her to put her life on hold, she wonders, how long does she fight?  And at what cost?

Then he has a good spell.  He eats and reads and tells jokes, tells her he loves her, gives his whole heart to the physical therapy exercises, talks of the future.  Things are bright and hopeful until they darken and he grabs her by her hair and delivers a stunning left hook to her jaw, making her see stars and cry out in pain.
He doesn't even know why and she retreats in fear and anger and despair, too hurt and emotionally exhausted to face another minute.  He will not remember this the next morning, will ask about her bruised and swollen jaw and be ready to shoot the sob who hit his baby girl and she will not know what to tell him.  And then by late afternoon, he'll be gone again - in his place, a frustrated, sick, brutal old man, shouting threats at all who come near, viciously raging against all who would help him.  There's no escape and no mercy.

Take him or give him back, she begs of God, and immediately regrets what she sees as selfishness.

The in-between times are the worst false promises.









Thursday, November 07, 2013

Smoke'em If You Got'em, Boys

Idle hands, my grandmother announces briskly over breakfast, are the devil's workshop.  It's a fine day to wash windows and stack wood.

The sunporch, glassed in on three sides, faces the ocean and it's my job to keep the windows clean.  Nana fills a bucket with soap and water and pulls out the long handled scrub brush.  She begins cleaning the inside glass and I start on the outside.  It's a beautiful summer day with sunlight sparkling on the waves - the high grass sways in the morning breeze and the flag snaps smartly each time it catches the wind.  Seagulls soar overhead and I hear the familiar chug-a-lug of the ferry making the crossing.  My mother is in the kitchen and I can smell the warm sweetness of bread just out of the old oven - Uncle Eddie and Aunt Helen are to arrive later today and there is to be fresh bread and fish chowder waiting for lunch - and in the backyard, my brothers are resentfully carrying armload after armload of cord wood from the new woodpile to the woodshed, stopping every now and again to sneak a forbidden cigarette out of a stolen pack of Kent 100's.  They think, wrongly, that Nana hasn't noticed, a fact that will be painfully clarified before the day is out.

After the windows are soaped and rinsed once then twice, they gleam and dry in the sun.  Nana pronounces the job well done and rewards me with a shiny new quarter and a strawberry tart then sends me upstairs to begin the process of stripping the beds.  She spends the remainder of the morning with the wringer washer until every sheet and pillow case has been fed through and hung out to dry, stopping at regular intervals to inspect the woodshed and make sure that the boys are stacking the wood neatly. 

If it's worth doing, she reminds them, it's worth doing well.  They grumble under their breaths but pick up their pace, eager to be done and released.  My mother moves on to pie making, two apple with sugar coated crusts and one blueberry with a delicate patchwork of crisscrossed pastry strips.  The kitchen fairly reeks with the smells of good country cooking - I may not like my mother much but on days like this I can't help but admire her skills - and I like the fact that with company coming, she and my grandmother have too much to do to quarrel.

Nana sets the finished pies on the window sill to cool.  Couldn't have done better myself, Jan, she says and my mother shrugs, trying to be self deprecating, but I can tell by her face that she's ridiculously pleased.  We are not a family that gives or accepts compliments often or well.

Not long after the noon whistle blows, a shiny new Cadillac makes the turn into the driveway and the dogs commence to barking.  My Uncle Eddie, wearing a tweed vest, with his handlebar mustache meticulously twirled and carrying a white handled walking stick - he looks startlingly like Mr. Monopoly - emerges with an ear to ear grin.

Put the kettle on, Alice! he shouts, We have arrived!   My Aunt Helen sits primly in the passenger seat, giving one last pat of powder to her nose and waiting expectantly for her car door to be opened as she considers it unladylike to do it herself.  She is very nearly forgotten in the rush of people and dogs and luggage and is forced to clear her throat - twice - before anyone notices and my uncle obediently returns to the Caddy, opens her door and offers her his hand.  She steps out, wrinkling her nose at the dust and gravel and clutching a delicate, lace edged handkerchief with her initials prominently embroidered in the corner in one pale hand and a Gucci purse in the other.  

Take my arm, old girl, Uncle Eddie says with an extravagant bow, I'll see you through this foreign land.

Alice, dear, she tells my grandmother, I'm simply done in by this primitive travel.  I could simply die for a cup of tea.

I'm sure, Helen, dear, Nana replies with her best company smile, Go right in.  

My least favorite aunt walks a little unsteadily across the uneven gravel drive and through the grass, each step in her polished low heeled pumps and nylon clad legs a challenge.  

What is that vile smell, Edgecomb?  she demands halfway to the back door.

Salt fish, old girl, he tells her cheerfully, Nothing like it on a grand summer afternoon!

Aunt Helen shivers with distaste and my grandmother, several steps behind, can only shake her head.

Only woman I know still wears seamed stockings, she mutters dismally, How did I get myself into this?

Lunch is a stilted and uncomfortable affair.  In hushed tones and only when my grandmother and mother leave the table,  Helen finds the chowder too salty, the bread overdone, the butter too soft.  

Apple or blueberry?  my mother inquires in a saccharine sweet semi-growl.

How agreeable it must be not to have to worry about one's figure, my aunt comments, shaking her head when passed a slice of blueberry pie smothered in real whip cream.  My mother's hand pauses, the dessert plate trembles and tips ever so slightly toward Helen's lap until Uncle Eddie smoothly slips a hand beneath it.

I'll take one of each, Jan, he says heartily and winks - my mother surrenders the dessert with obvious reluctance - and Helen obliviously continues to prattle on about the menace of sugar and improper nutrition while my grandmother does her best to hide a slightly sly smile.  

More coffee, Helen, dear? she asks so sweetly it almost makes my teeth hurt.

Oh, I think not, Alice, Aunt Helen says airily, I've had quite enough. 

You have no idea, I think to myself.

It is then that Nana quite calmly pulls out a pack of Kent 100's from her apron pocket and offers one to each of my brothers.  A few seconds of stunned silence ensue then the boys regroup, exchange glances, and put on their misunderstood, wrongly accused faces, each trying - not very convincingly- to appear bewildered. My grandmother smiles but there's no humor in it.  

Oh, but I insist, she says firmly when they shake their heads in unison and try to back away.  They look desperately to my mother but there's no help there - she just shrugs indifferently - meanwhile, Nana takes a second pack from her pocket and places one each in front of each brother along with a book of matches.  Light up, she says encouragingly, We all know you know how.

The boys scuffle and look away but by then Uncle Eddie is standing behind them, hands gripping the backs of their chairs and holding them in place.  Aunt Helen is staring open mouthed and quite prepared to faint, I suspect but Nana ignores her and deliberately lights two cigarettes and hands them across the table.  Finally grasping that there's no escape, my brothers take them with badly shaking hands and very pale faces - the older inhales and blows smoke with a defiant smirk, the younger hesitantly follows suit but without the bravado - and Nana nods with a kind of grim satisfaction.  When both cigarettes are smoked to the filter, she hands them each other.

Good, she says and now there is absolute malice in her tone and ice in her eyes, One down, nineteen to go. 
Smoke'em if you got'em, boys.  Let's see how grown up you really are.

She never gave an inch, not when their eyes began to water, not when they coughed, not when both were greenish and sick and begging.  My mother left the table, Aunt Helen and Uncle Eddie excused themselves to unpack and change clothes, I slipped away unnoticed, but Nana sat quietly until both cigarette packs were empty and my brothers were nearly comatose with nicotine.  Harsh as it was, the lesson was short lived, but for the remainder of that summer at least, no more Kent 100's went missing.  

Well, Alice, Aunt Helen remarked, I suppose you think they'll never smoke after that little debacle.

Don't be an idiot, Helen, Uncle Eddie said mildly, It was never about smoking.

Helen blinked in surprise and he patted her cashmere'd shoulder gently.  Then what? she asked in genuine bewilderment.

Uncle Eddie gave my grandmother a knowing grin.  It was about taking things that aren't yours, he said kindly, It was about stealing, wouldn't you say, Alice?

But Nana just smiled and reached for her knitting.
















Sunday, November 03, 2013

Spare Me Your Tears

Not for the first time, I read an online post from a "grief stricken" cat owner, only this time - perhaps because of the presence of a new kitten in the house, one who would surely have died without intervention - I found myself unable to shrug and move past it.  Of the 17 cats who I've shared my life with, only two died prematurely and neither from lack of care or love.  So if you choose to put your cat in harm's way and it's crushed under the wheels of an SUV, then please spare me your heartbreak.  What exactly did you think was likely to happen?

I have friends who have dogs as well as cats and most would never dream of violating the leash law and letting their dogs run free and at risk.  They are responsible owners for the most part - they keep up to date on vaccinations and veterinary care and provide safe, loving homes.  And yet a fair number see nothing whatever wrong with letting their cats roam at will - to be neighborhood nuisances, to be stolen, to go missing, to be mauled by dogs or other cats, to be trapped, to breed, to be struck and killed by a car on a busy city street. I can't reconcile their grief with their casual neglect or the easy replacements they seem to immediately take in. I won't accept their arguments that cats were meant to be outside or that to deny them the feel of the sun or their faces is cruel nor that they have some special immunity that dogs lack.  If you choose not to do all in your power to keep them safe, then please spare me your anguish when they're killed.  What exactly did you think was likely to happen?

These friends will, I have no doubt, come at me with tales of their 18 year old tabbies who have never wandered an inch off their property and wonderful, happy stories of cats who live in the country, far removed from the hazards of city life.  They will protest the idea of confinement as cruel and unusual and assure me that a cat's natural instinct is to prowl.  I'll hear about tough-minded, independent and street-wise cats who have lived long and well being free  to come and go at their leisure.  Their cats would never dream of killing someone's beloved songbirds or trespassing and destroying a flower garden.  Their cats would never seek shelter in a car engine or fall into a storm drain.  Their cats can take care of themselves - they know the limits of their yards and respect the boundaries - they'll never be snakebit or drink antifreeze or tangle with hostile wildlife or cruel children with rocks and worse.


Good for you, I'll tell them, I'm happy for you.  You and your cat have been lucky.  But it doesn't change the fact that an average outside cat's life expectancy is three years.  So if you choose to put your cat at risk, spare me your regret when something horrific - or worse, unknown - befalls them.  What exactly did you think was likely to happen?


Cats are not indestructible or disposable or self-sufficient.  They can't outrun traffic or predators and they don't sit around longing for the outside world.  Find them a window sill or a sun spot, build them an enclosure or get a dog.  If you love them, then keep them safe or spare me your tears.